In a recent profile of the band in the New York Times, the Arcade Fire’s Will Butler (the brother of founding member and main lead vocalist Win Butler) described his band, saying, “It was art rock. It wasn’t attitude rock.” But after listening to their 2004 release, Funeral, which I received as a birthday present from my sister that year, my initial reaction was that it was indeed ‘attitude rock’, albeit an exceeding well crafted example of thereof. While I enjoyed the musical textures the band achieved on the album, I just couldn’t understand the melodramatic angst that is best exemplified by the opening track, “Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)”. I simply could not locate the source of the desperation that lay behind Win Butler’s over-the-top delivery, nor could I imagine how a group of seemingly privileged white kids from Canada (and the US) could be capable of the emotional depth that they attempt on Funeral. I was 25 and angry, having known real desperation in my own journey through life, and what I heard was a mimicry of real emotion. But the instrumentals and arranging were so compelling that I kept returning to the album’s rich soundscapes, catchy hooks, and idiosyncratic instrumentations.
It was the rediscovery of “Haiti”, a couple years later, that opened a door into the ontology of the Arcade Fire. I came across it while selecting music for an early morning political talk radio show that I hosted weekly for a year. The Regine Chassagne’s lyrics, which in less able hands could have come across as overreaching, are produced to sound as though they are sung from afar and set amid a pastoral collage of back porch acoustic guitar and bass, gentle surf sounds, and synthesizers. It’s a great example of the Arcade Fire grounding their far-reaching artistic vision in understatement. On The Suburbs the Arcade Fire succeed in just this way.
Perhaps it’s not fair for me to review this album, since I first listened to it today on a two hour bike ride from Midtown Manhattan over the George Washington and into Northern Jersey. I tend to form my strongest musical connections this way (although it didn’t work for M.I.A.’s most recent album) . As I rode down the Hudson River bikeway towards the bridge, my reaction to the first few tracks was disappointment, and I have not yet been able in subsequent listenings to develop any fondness for the first 5 songs, except for the opening track “The Suburbs” which mades sense when its themes are reprised later in the album. That track aside, the first 20 minutes or so of this album felt like more of the same for the Arcade Fire, and I was prepared for the album to be a disappointment. But as I passed West Harlem Piers Park, however, “City with No Children” caught my attention with it’s straightforward lyrical delivery. From there on, and with the help of some fine songs from Chassagne, the album builds steadily and begins to take on a shape of it’s own. As I neared the top of the GWB, “Suburban War” played, sounding a little bit like Stephin Merritt singing Beck’s “Jack-Ass”, and ultimately building to a crescendo and then a long fade out that I mistook for the end of the album.
But it wasn’t the end… it was what I would call then end of Side A (The Suburbs is just over an hour long, so it would be a little bit lengthy for a good sounding LP). Side B traces a journey back into the suburbs, and the beginning of that journey is the rather generic rocker “Month of May”. But with the next song, “Wasted Hours” the journey to the suburbs that we are promised begins in earnest. This song is a lament for the lost time and lost youth in the empty existence of suburban youth. Well worn territory for sure, but done with grace, and perhaps a more authentic expression the pain and longing that came across as melodramatic, juvenile angst on Funeral. It was an opportunity to empathize with Butler. Like Butler, I am also 30 years old. I lament the loss of time, the loss of youth. I watch the talented people around me fill their lives with meaning through their accomplishments, while struggle to be the many things that I have become or wish to be: a musician, a lover, a scientist, a cook, a global citizen, an actor, an athlete, an activist, a writer, a member of my community, a member of my family. But I find myself forced to specialize, which means giving up some of these identities and goals, and I struggle to love how my choices have transformed me and to avoid regretting as wasted the hours I spent chasing other dreams. Perhaps it’s just me that has changed, but it seems that Butler has hit the mark as a songwriter on this album, correcting the excesses and that were evident on Funeral, and writing more with more emotional honesty. He’s just more believable as a 30 year old man coming to grips with his past in the suburbs and his present in the city.
“Sprawl II (Mountains Beyond Mountains)” is somewhat of an anomaly in the context, but it’s a catchy pop tune reminiscent of Blondie or Cyndi Lauper, or contemporaries Ladytron. Inexplicably, it name checks the title of Tracy Kidder’s biography of Partners in Health founder Dr. Paul Farmer. During their current tour, as they have on previous tours, the band is donating $1 of each ticket sold to Partners in Health’s Stand with Haiti relief and reconstruction fund. I’ll be at their Madison Square Garden Show tomorrow night.










